Peer review

Waymarking Waymarking
1

Waymarkujem už nejaký ten piatok, ale stále mi nie je jasné, kedy Category proposal prejde cez Peer review, a kedy nie. V zásade:

  1. Kto môže hlasovať? Len PM, alebo aj BM?
  2. Ako dlho hlasovanie trvá? Zo skúsenosti viem, že asi tak 2-3 dni.
  3. A hlavne - čo sa deje potom? Kto rozhoduje o výsledku hlasovania? Machine, alebo Groundspeak lackey? Stačí nadpolovičná väčšina, alebo treba viac?

:o:p:o

2

Tak vám ďakujem za všetky odpovede, čakal som v napätí celé 2 roky pri počítači, ale už ma to nebaví a idem preč.

Čaute.

:rolleyes:

3

:D a já vůl už chtěl hledat odpověď...

 

Tak jen pro případné další hledače odpovědí…

What is Peer Review? How does it work?

Peer Review consists of a queue available to all Premium Members allowing them to review, vote, and comment on category hopefuls. Voting lasts for 3 days and is anonymous unless you elect to make your vote public. As a general rule of thumb, a two-thirds majority is necessary to pass a category. In the case where a category is on the fence, Groundspeak reserves the right to make the final decision, but in most cases we will err on the side of approving the category. One of the things to keep in mind when voting on categories is that some people have a different idea of what is “wow!” If you think a number of people will enjoy the category, even if you won’t personally, you should vote “yea” and perhaps give some recommendations for improvement.

What happens if my category fails Peer Review?

In the off chance the community disliked your category, it will be archived and your Group will need to start over. It’s not recommended to submit the same category to Peer Review more than a couple times.